🖌️ Fix the Gradient Tool’s Dither Option Creating Visible Banding in Exported PNGs Despite Looking Smooth on Canvas
The Gradient tool’s Dither option scatters a fine random noise pattern into the gradient so your eye blends adjacent bands together on screen, but that dithering is computed against the document’s current working bit depth at the moment you draw the gradient. Exporting to an 8-bit PNG re-quantizes every pixel afterward, and if the gradient was drawn on an 8-bit canvas to begin with, the dither pattern has nowhere near enough tonal headroom to hide the steps once a color profile conversion or PNG palette optimization happens during export – so a gradient that looked perfectly smooth in the Photoshop window comes out visibly banded in the delivered file.
🔎 The Problem
Document: 8-bit/channel, sRGB Gradient tool: Dither checked, long smooth sky gradient drawn On canvas (zoomed to 100%): looks smooth, no visible steps File > Export As > PNG-24: Visible horizontal banding reappears in the blue sky area Image > Mode: still shows "8 Bits/Channel" - dithering had only 256 levels per channel to work with the whole time, the on-canvas smoothness was display-level anti-aliasing, not extra tonal data the export could preserve.
✅ Fix: Give the Gradient Real Bit Depth Before You Dither It
- Switch the document to 16-bit/channel (Image > Mode > 16 Bits/Channel) before drawing the gradient, then convert back to 8-bit only at the very end, right before export – dithering has far more tonal levels to distribute noise across, so the bands genuinely don’t exist rather than being disguised.
- If the file must stay 8-bit throughout, add a thin Noise layer (Filter > Noise > Add Noise, Gaussian, a very small amount) above the gradient and flatten before export – this bakes dither-like noise directly into the pixel data instead of relying on the tool’s preview-time dithering.
- Check the export dialog’s own color profile handling – a ‘Convert to sRGB’ step during Export As can itself reintroduce banding in a gradient that was fine right up to that conversion, so compare a version exported with and without the conversion when banding appears.
🚨 Why This Is Dangerous
- This kind of banding is often invisible on your monitor but obvious on a client’s cheaper display or in print, so a gradient approved by eye on your own screen is not a reliable sign-off – check the actual exported file, not just the canvas, before calling a gradient finished.
Dither hides banding at preview time – it doesn’t add the tonal data back once the export quantizes the image down again.
