🖌️ Fix a Custom Brush Preset Painting at the Wrong Size Because Its Saved Scale Was Captured While a Transform Was Still Active
Saving a brush preset via the brush picker’s “New Brush Preset” records the Size slider’s value exactly as it stands at that instant – including any temporary multiplier left over from bracket-key resizing you forgot you’d applied while testing a stroke. Every future stroke with that preset starts from that frozen number instead of the brush tip’s intended size.
🔎 The Problem
Brush Settings panel, Brush Tip Shape:
Size: 180px (expected ~45px, the tip's native size)
Steps that produced this:
1. Selected a 45px brush tip
2. Pressed ']' repeatedly to size up while testing a
stroke, reaching 180px
3. Opened the brush picker, clicked the 'New Brush
Preset' icon without resetting Size first
4. Preset saved with Size = 180px baked in as its
default, not 45px
Every new document that loads this preset starts every
stroke at 180px until Size is manually reset again.
✅ Fix: Reset Size Before Saving, or After the Fact
- Before clicking New Brush Preset, reset Size to the value you actually want baked in as the default – bracket-key changes made while testing are exactly what gets captured if you save before resetting.
- For an already-saved preset, open Brush Settings, set Size to the correct value, then save over the same preset name via New Brush Preset again to overwrite its stored default.
- Check ‘Size’ in the New Brush Preset dialog’s capture options only when you genuinely want the current slider value locked in – unchecking it keeps the preset’s size tied to whatever you leave the Size slider at per-session instead.
🚨 Why This Is Dangerous
- A brush preset shared with someone else carries this baked-in size silently – they’ll get the same wrong starting size on their first stroke with no indication anything was overridden.
A brush preset remembers exactly what the Size slider said the moment you clicked save – not what you meant it to say.

